Oneseat Club

Peer advisory group vs mastermind vs referral group

Updated

A peer advisory group helps you make better decisions about the company (Vistage, EO, YPO). A mastermind keeps you moving with hot seats and commitments. A referral group brings you clients: one member per trade, who pass each other work (BNI, LeTip, Oneseat Club).

The three kinds of groups, from their published formats
Advisory groupMastermindReferral group
You come away withAdvice on decisionsAccountability, ideasClients
ExamplesVistage, EO, YPO, HamptonPaid or self-run groupsBNI, LeTip, Oneseat Club
Size6 to 168 to 10 is commonOne per trade
RhythmMonthlyMonthly or quarterlyWeekly
Led byA Chair or moderatorsMembers or an organizerMembers, under set rules
First year$6,130 to about $19,060Free, or about $4,200 at the median$171 to about $1,500

Peer advisory group

Vistage defines it as a group of CEOs, owners or key executives "committed to helping each other make better decisions". Members bring their hardest decisions; the group asks questions and shares experience. Built for company leaders (what Vistage costs).

Mastermind

A peer-to-peer mentoring group where members solve their problems with each other's input. (What happens in a meeting.)

Referral group

Members don't advise each other; they send each other work. The rule that makes it work is one member per trade, so nobody competes for the same client, and a give rule, so everyone keeps passing clients.

Which one do you need?

  • A hard decision ahead, and a company big enough to qualify: a peer advisory group.
  • Stuck, or moving too slowly: a mastermind.
  • Not enough clients: a referral group.

Launch offer: your first 3 months, free for the first 100.

Freelancer serving Shopify brands? Oneseat Club (that's us): 15 freelancers, one seat per trade, who send each other clients. Every Monday, each member posts the client they want. Introduce one client every six weeks to keep your seat. No meetings, no commission. $19 a month after the free months, no card to start.

See if my trade's seat is free

Questions

Is Vistage a mastermind?

Vistage calls itself a peer advisory group: 12 to 16 members, a full day a month, and a paid Chair who also coaches each member one to one. Many people use both words loosely.

Is BNI a mastermind group?

No. BNI is a referral group: one member per profession, who meet weekly to pass each other referrals.

Can one group do all three?

Rarely well. Advice and referrals pull meetings in different directions; most groups pick one and do it properly.

Sources